Tuesday, July 14, 2015

Evaluative Criteria Annotations of Comtemporary Realistic Fiction Children's Books


Cleary, Beverly. 1983. Dear Mr.Henshaw. Ill. by P. O. Zelinsky. New York: HarperTrophy.

            Leigh Botts is a boy who is going through a rough time due to his parents’ divorce and moving to a new town. He is not adjusting well in the new town and having to deal with his anger and sadness about his parents’ situation at the same time is not helping him at all. That is until a class assignment requires him to write to an author. Written in the style of letters addressed to Mr.Henshaw, the author Leigh has chosen to write to, the reader can see how Leigh’s writing gets better as his interest in writing increases and as he starts maturing in the process. The view of gender is prevalent in the story as the reader sees how, as a boy, Leigh struggles with his feelings and the absence of a good father figure. Culture, not as race but as in society, is also prevalent as we see how conflicted Leigh is with his feelings about divorce and seeing his parents date again.  (Gender & Culture, Style)

Draper, Sharon. 2010. Out of my mind. New York: Atheneum Books for Young Readers

            The main character in the story is Melody who has cerebral palsy and cannot move or talk but despite what others may believe, she can think. She gets assistance with a machine that would allow her to communicate with others. Everyone is in disbelief of how intelligent she is but still belittle her triumphs along the way due to her disability. The theme of the story is about the struggles that teens with disabilities face in school and in society when people think they are not capable of them making their own decisions and being good at something independently. Melody’s character demonstrates this when she tries out for the quiz team and succeeds in making the team. Her efforts are still trumped by her peers when Melody receives more acknowledgement than the entire team. Throughout the story her feelings become complicated for trying to make a difference and yet still being brought down by peers.

Lord, Cynthia. 2006. Rules. United States: Scholastic Press

            Catherine’s life as well as her autistic brother David’s are lived by rules created by Catherine to avoid embarrassing situations more for herself than for David which can be seen throughout the story and as headings for each chapter. As Catherine narrates this uplifting but at times heartbreaking story, the reader can see how stressed she becomes from having to look after her brother and even a sense of abandonment from her parents for her relying so much on her for the well-being of David. Catherine tries to keep it together while trying to make a new social life for herself with her new neighbor Kristi. Her point of view changes when she meets Jason, a nonverbal paraplegic, at David’s therapy clinic whom she communicates with through his communication book and even designs cards for. Jason makes her see that it shouldn’t matter what people think about her when she is around him or David and should only focus on what is really important: happiness. (Characters, theme, style)  

Pastis, Stephan. 2013. Timmy Failure: Mistakes Were Made. Indiana. Candlewick Press

            Timmy Failure is written in a style similar to Diary of a Wimpy Kid with comical illustrations made by Timmy himself. The humorous story is about Timmy’s attempt at being the best detective alongside his imaginary bear friend Total. The story, narrated by Timmy, described all of his delusional adventures alongside with his illustrations and his efforts to fix mysteries and mistakes but fails to do so effectively while pinpoint some of his own mistakes and flaws in a comical way. Timmy can be described as imaginative but almost delusional with a high sense of superiority although his way of thinking as well as his trouble with school and home life beg to differ. Although that is the case, it is astounding the world Timmy creates for himself to bring a sense of happiness and control in his life in a very humorous way. (Characters, Style, Plot)

Paterson, Katherine. 1977. Bridge to Terabithia. Ill. by D.Diamond. New York: HarperTrophy.

            The characters Jess Aarons and Leslie Burke form an unlikely friendship at school when they try to see who the fastest runner is. Leslie’s imagination and in collaboration with Jess, they create a magical kingdom named Terabithia where they reign as royalty and makes for an interesting setting for the story. Terabithia is a place where both friends escape from their troublesome lives and go on many adventures together. The character of Jess changes in the course of the story after Leslie’s passing and makes him mature and gather strength to overcome his struggles. (Characters, Setting)

Urban, Linda. 2009. A Crooked Kind of Perfect. United States: HMH Books for Young Readers.

            The title for the book is very fitting to what the Zoe’s life in the story entails. Zoe starts wanting to own a grand piano but ends up getting an organ instead. With the help of her slightly dysfunctional family and unexpected friends, she goes through the organ lessons and signs up for the annual Perform – O – Rama organ competition but does not expect too much out of it due to how things in her social life have been going. The plot of the story is a slightly complex one with all the little bumps happening in Zoe’s life that keep her from her main goal but she still ends with a happy ending. The author’s chosen style of writing although short within chapters did not abruptly pause the story but led to Zoe’s actions and thought processes. (Plot, Style)

No comments:

Post a Comment