Friday, July 10, 2015

Evaluation Criteria for Picture Books


Characters
 

The character of Max in the story “Where the Wild Things Are” by Maurice Sendak has a behavior that is age appropriate to the intended reading audience. Max starts off in the story being mischievous which leads him to trouble, throwing a tantrum and being sent to his room with no dinner. His imagination starts to wander and he goes in an adventure where he becomes King of the Wild Things due to his bravery and being “the wildest thing of them all”. Just like any child away from home he starts to miss his mother and gives up his throne to go home. His strong sense of self and well as his wild imagination make him a remarkable character in the story.

Plot
 

In the book “This is Not My Hat” by Jon Klassen, the narrator of the story is the small fish. The small fish just stole a hat and he is convinced that he will not get caught. Throughout the story he remains convinced they will not find him. The pictures, on the other hand, demonstrate otherwise as the reader sees the others characters emotions and actions. The reader is engaged because they keep wondering if perhaps the small fish will indeed not get caught somehow. The pictures in the story play an enormous part in the plot of the story.

Setting
 

The story “It’s a Book” by Lane Smith has the common setting of a house. The most important thing about the setting of this particular story is not only the location of where the story takes place but the time period. The monkey’s (main character) friend the jackass keeps asking what the monkey is using because he’s absolutely dumbfounded as to what it is. The rabbit keeps asking the monkey questions using technology jargon. The use of rabbit’s technology terms makes it quite evident that it is a story that is taking place right now as we speak.

Theme
 

“The Paperbag Princess” by Robert Munsch has many themes. Such themes are about being witty and outsmarting your way out of a troubling situation, and finding yourself valuable and surrounding yourself by those who think the same while getting rid of those who don’t. Elizabeth outsmarted the dragon to save Ronald. After she did, Robert looked down on Elizabeth because she was dirty from the dragon’s flames. Elizabeth’s pride and self-worth allowed her to leave Ronald due to his lack of appreciation for what she did for him. It was a great closure to the story and made Elizabeth look smart and powerful and not like a damsel in distress which is how princesses are often portrayed.

Illustrations
 

In “The Three Pigs” by David Wiesner we can see various types of illustrations throughout the book. It starts with simple and light-colored pictures. As the story continues we see the pigs jump out of the story and attain a more three dimensional form and different ranges of color. The pigs enter a nursery rhyme and their illustrations change again into a very simplified animation with the use of pastel colors. The pigs jump into another story that transforms them into black and white characters. All the switches in illustration types allow the reader to really see how the pigs come alive as they are jumping into different stories. You can also see falling text and crumpled pages as the pigs dismantle their story. These types of illustrations allow the reader to really believe that what is happening in the story is like a reality.

Cultural Markers
 

The Legend of the Bluebonnet by Tommie DePaola is one that most definitely depicts cultural markers.  DePaola is widely known for depicting various cultures in his works. The Legend of the Bluebonnet is based on an old Texas tale and Native Americans. Although its accuracy cannot be verified within the book due to it being based on a tale, the story does a very good job about demonstrating Native American life in a non-stereotypical way through its use of appropriate skin tones and attire as well as terms such as Native American names.

No comments:

Post a Comment